[*] = GOOD [50/50] = AVERAGE/ALRIGHT/Difference in Opinion [X] = BAD [N/A] = NO REACTION/NOT SURE

Season 1:

Cthulu Card Game-

Dankenstein IIPA (Pearl Street Brewery) an Imperial for shitfucks. 9.5% *Rotating Availability*

Blackened Voodoo Lager (Dixie Brewing Company) a dark ale. 5.0% *Year-Round*


Black Scotch Ale (O’so Brewing Company & Tap House) fine and rich unlike divorce parents. 6.3% *Rotating Availability*

Wasatch Polygamy Porter (Utah Brewers Cooperative) tastes like mud. 4.0% *Year-Round*

New Holland Dragon’s Milk -Bourbon Barrel Stout- (New Holland Brewing Company) really good beer dancing in an oak bath. 10.0% *Year-Round*

“Magic the Gathering”-

Sheep Shagger Scotch Ale (Tyranena Brewing Company) All foam. 7.5% *Fall*

Luna Coffee Stout (Hinterland Brewery Restaurant) a very excitable stout. 5.6% *Year-Round*

Delirium Tremens (Brouwerij Huyghe) 8.5% *Year-Round*

Dark Tower-

Sierra Nevada Glissade Golden Bock (Sierra Nevada Brewing Co.) 6.4% *Winter*

Monty Python’s Holy Grail Ale (Black Sheep Brewery PLC) a shitty pale ale 4.7% *Year-Round*

New Holland The Poet Oatmeal Stout (New Holland Brewing Company) pair well with mushrooms and beef..tastes like shit 5.2% *Year-Round*


Family Feud-

Two Women Lager (New Glarus Brewing Company) brewed with Weyermann’s floor malted Bohemian malt and Hallertau Mittelfrueh hops. 5.0% *Year-Round*

Skull Splitter (Orkney Brewery) Caramel hints..get fucked 8.5% *Year-Round*

Sticky McDoogle Scotch Ale (Ale Asylum) hoppy, fruity and has personality. 7.2% *Year-Round*

$20,000 Pyramid-

Samuel Adams Summer Ale (Boston Beer Company) bitter, smooth, odd. 5.3% *Summer*

Imperial Stout (Mendocino Brewing Company) 10.0% *Year-Round*

Trivial Pursuit-

Storm King Stout (Victory Brewing Company) 9.1% *Year-Round*

Founders Devil Dancer (Founders Brewing Company) 12.0% *Rotating Availability*

Axis and Allies-

American Amber Ale (Rogue Ales) 5.6% *Year-Round*

Buckler (Heineken Nederland B.V.) non-alcoholic% *year-round*

Operation (and Mad Libs)-

Kentucky Bourbon Barrel Ale (Alltech’s Lexington Brewing and Distilling Co.) “It smells mediciney..” -Matt “It’s bourbony.” -Jason “We gonna get fucked up early tonight!” -Aaron 8.19% *Year-Round*

Hudy 14-K (Hudepohl-Schoenling Brewing Co.) “tastes like apples” -Matt “What?!” -Aaron 4.4% *Year-Round*

Hudepohl Amber Lager (Hudepohl-Schoenling Brewing Co.) ??% *Fall*


Short’s The Magician (Short’s Brewing Company) Dark red London style ale, looks like Feuhorbe cover art, “I don’t like it, its like a tart cherry” -Matt, “Not as magical as I was lead to believe” -Aaron 6.0% *Winter*

Atwater Voodoo Vator (Atwater Brewery) “it is good, smokey and mellow” -Matt 9.5% *Year-Round*

Mystery Mansion-

Dragonmead Final Absolution Trippel (Dragonmead Microbrewery) 8.5% *Year-Round*

Founders Dirty Bastard (Founders Brewing Company) “It tastes like meat” -Matt 8.5% *Year-Round*

Game of Life-

Winter Skål (Capital Brewery) “One of my favorite yearly beers” -Aaron It’s quite a hoppy beer, crisp and wintery” -Matt 5.4% *Winter*

Founders Breakfast Stout (Founders Brewing Company) 8.3% *Fall*

Mr. Gameshow-

Guinness Black Lager (Guinness Ltd.) “Frothy, Delicious” -Jason, “It’ll do” -Aaron, “Doesn’t really knock your socks off” -Matt 4.5% *Rotating Availability*

Batch 19: Pre-Prohibition Style Lager (Coors Brewing Company) “It has more depth than the typical lager” -Matt 5.5% *Year-Round*

Improv Comedy Game-

New Grist Sorghum Beer (Lakefront Brewery, Inc.) “Tastes like a Belgian beer” -Matt, “Like a Belgian White” -Jason, “Doesn’t taste like a Belgian to me” -Aaron 5.75% *Year-Round*

How the Grinch Stole Christmas-

Great Lakes Christmas Ale (Great Lakes Brewing Co.) “It’s not overly sweet as I was afraid of.” -Matt, “This is finally a beer I enjoy on this show.” -Dylan “This tastes like Christmas potpourri a little bit.” -Paul, “I like it.” -Aaron 7.5% *Winter*


Bell’s Christmas Ale (Bell’s Brewery, Inc.) “I enjoy most Bell’s beer” -Aaron 5.4% *Winter*

Cards Against Humanity-

Apples to Apples-

Kraken Black Spiced Rum (Prumixo Spirits) “Oh God! It tastes like drinking a cigar.” -Aaron, “-sobbing uncontrollably- I couldn’t help that” -Matt  47.0%

Estrella Damm Daura (Damm S. A.) “It has a distinct urine color, tastes like regular beer” -Matt, “It’s won awards you know!” -Brad 5.4% *Year-Round*

Bard’s Gold (Bard’s Tale Beer Company, LLC) “Tastes like licking a silo.” -Matt, “Tastes like OFF mosquito spray.” -Aaron 4.6% *Year-Round*


Louie’s Demise Immort-Ale (Milwaukee Brewing Company) 4.8% *Year-Round*

Wasatch The Devastator Double Bock (Utah Brewers Cooperative) “No Flavor” -Matt, “It tastes like beer.” -Aaron 8% *Winter*



Season 2:

-Mystery Date-&-Cards Against Humanity-

[*] 1. Alaskan Winter Ale (Alaskan Brewing Co.) “It doesn’t really taste like a Winter Ale, Winter Ales are more Hardy and Husky and taste like overweight children. This beer is Dylan” -Matt. 6.4%ABV *Winter*

[X] 2. Big Eddy Russian Imperial Stout (Jacob Leinenkugel Brewing Co.) “It tastes like Soy Sauce!” – Dylan, “It tastes like soy sauce.. it really does.” -Matt. 9.5%ABV *Rotating Availability*

-Balderdash-&-Ripley’s Believe It or Not-

[50/50] 3. Lindemans Kriek/Framboise/Pêche (Brouwerij Lindemans) “It tastes just like fruit juice.” -Aaron, “I would put this in a sippy cup and give it to a toddler” -Jason (I wonder if he will follow through? Probably not.). 4.0%/2.50%/2.50%ABV. *Year-Round*

[*] 4. Furious (Surly Brewing Company) “This looks like beer, I’ve been wanting this all night..This beer and the last beer are like night and day.” -Matt, “It tastes very hoppy.” -Aaron, “Wow!” -Jason. 6.2%ABV. *Rotating Availability*



[50/50] 5. Alaskan White Wheat Ale (Alaskan Brewing Co.) “Tastes like a summer beer.” -Paul, “Well it has a bear on it in the arctic, which doesn’t exist anymore, all the polar bears are dead.” -Aaron. 5.3%ABV. *Winter*

[***] 6. English Trifle/BOOZE CAKE (Courtney Collins) A cold dessert of sponge cake and fruit covered with layers of custard, jelly, and cream.. and booze. N/A%ABV. *Birthday Availability*

[50/50] 7. Thumbprint Barley Wine – (New Glarus Brewing Co.) “That’s really weird for a barley wine, it’s really hoppy for a barley wine.” -Aaron, “That tastes like taint. It is like a tranquilizer dart in your ass.” -Paul. 12.0%ABV. *Limited*

-Candyland-&-Sex Maniacs-

[*] 8. Turbodog (Abita Brewing Co.) “I sent back an Abita beer once, it must have been a faulty tap.. this is ok, I won’t be sending it back.” -Matt, “It’s pretty good.” -Aaron. 5.6%ABV. *Year-Round*

[*] 9. Winter Solstice Seasonal Ale (Anderson Valley Brewing Co.) “It’s really sweet.. it’s got a good flavor I just wish it was a little more subtle.” -Matt, “I like it. It still tastes really beer-y” -Aaron. 6.9%ABV. *Winter*


-Good Sex w/Dr. Ruth- & -Pimp-

[50/50] 10. Woodchuck Hard Cider Private Reserve Belgian White (Vermont Hard Cider Co.) “”It’s very subtle.” -Brad, “It’s pretty good as far as Ciders go, but it is still a cider so… meh.” -Matt, “I like it!” -Greg B. 5.5%ABV. *ultra-limited edition*

[X] 11. Sierra Nevada Ruthless Rye IPA (Sierra Nevada Brewing Co.) “It’s quite hoppy, I don’t think you’ll like it. It is Ruthless” -Matt, “Oh god…” -Aaron. 6.6%ABV. *Spring*

[X] 12. Dark Horse Scotty Karate Scotch Ale (Dark Horse Brewing Co.) “Wow! That’s a smokey Scotch Ale.” -Matt, “huh, that is smokey, tastes kinda like meat.” -Aaron, “Ohhhh…. guh, it tastes like beer.”-Greg. 9.75%ABV. *Fall*
-Payday- !!Matt’s Birthday!! -Go For Broke-

[N/A] 13. Icehouse (Miller Brewing Co.) “Before I knew what good beer was this was the beer that I chose to drink way too often.” -Matt. 5.5%ABV. *Year-Round*

[*] 14. Fat Squirrel Ale (New Glarus Brewing Company) “This beer is my favorite beer, I’ve been drinking it for 5 years and I never get tired of it. It’s sweet and it’s nutty.” -Matt, “Malty, tasty, it’s real good.” -Sean. 5.8%ABV. *Year-Round*

[*] 15. Samuel Adams Noble Pils (Boston Beer Company) “This is a very wonderful beer that Samuel Adams makes, this is the kind of beer I like because it doesn’t have that horrible IPA-ness to it that makes it taste like urine.” -Dylan, “This beer IS hoppy.” -Matt. 4.9%ABV. *Year-Round*

[50/50] 16. HopDevil Lager (Victory Brewing Company) “Oh wow, this is really good.” -Matt, “I’m not agreeing with that. I think it’d be better if you eliminated the hops, the taste of it would be fine, but it’d just tastes awful.” -Aaron, “It’s called HopDevil..” -Matt, “…….” -Aaron. 6.5%ABV. *Limited: Retired*

[*] 17. Hazelnut BrownNectar (Rogue Ales) “I like the taste! …Brown beer is becoming my favorite types of beers. Like a Scotch Ale it’s always pretty good.” -Aaron, “That’s quite good, thats very good. The Hazelnut is REALLY subtle.” -Matt. 6.2%ABV. *Year-Round*

[50/50] 18. Dragonhead Stout (Orkney Brewery) “I don’t care for smokey flavors in beer.” -Matt, “It’s vaguely meaty, but it’s not offensive. …Its probably low calorie too..” -Aaron, “It’s not bad though. …What?! Screw this beer!” -Vanessa. 7.0%ABV. *Year-Round*
-Angry Birds-

[50/50] 19. Lilja’s Hell Hound Brown Ale (Sand Creek Brewing Company) “Very hoppy brown, this tastes like an IPA to me.” -Matt, “It’s not like an IPA, No it doesn’t!” -Vanessa. 5.6%ABV. *Rotating Availability*
-Game of Thrones Game-

[*] 20. Great Lakes The Doppelrock (Great Lakes Brewing Co.) “Really high alcohols like this tend to get syrupy and thick but this is crisp and refreshing. Oh that’s gonna get us real drunk, it goes down so easy.” -Matt, “I like this, it rocks my doppel.” -Aaron. 7.8%ABV. *Spring*

[N/A] 21. Summit Maibock (Summit Brewing Company) “This is quite bitter but not in a hoppy way. It’s really crisp and bitter.” -Matt. 6.7%ABV. *Spring*
-MouseTrap-&-Cootie-&-Don’t Wake Daddy-

[50/50] 22. Anchor Steam Beer (Anchor Brewing Company) “That’s pretty good, it tastes like beer ya know.. I cant really go any farther than that.” -Aaron. 4.9%ABV. *Year-Round*

[X] 23. Boddingtons Pub Ale (Boddingtons) “Mmmm… It’s so bland.” -Andrew, “It’s like drinking in the red zone.” -Paul, “It tastes kinda like harp to me, and I don’t care for harp.” -Matt. 4.7%ABV. *Year-Round*
-Star Wars Epic Duels-&-Mad Libs-

[50/50] 24. Shiner Bock (Spoetzl Brewery) “Shiner Bock is a little underwhelming, however very refreshing and crisp for a dark beer.” -Matt, “I find it loquacious and uh succulent” -Dylan. 4.4%ABV. *Summer*

[50/50] 25. Four Witches (New Holland Brewing Company) “Oh Lordy-poo that is good!” -Dylan, “The licorice taste is a little too far out front for me but this is not a bad beer.” -Matt. 7.3%ABV. *Year-Round*

[50/50] 26. Leffe Brune / Brown (Abbaye de Leffe S.A.) “It doesn’t taste that belgiany it tastes more browny.” -Aaron. 6.5%ABV. *Year-Round*

[50/50] 27. Delirium Tremens (Brouwerij Huyghe) “It is foamy as shit! It has a hint of bananas” -Matt. 8.5%ABV. *Year-Round*

[*] 28. Boont Amber Ale (Anderson Valley Brewing Company) “I think it tastes pretty good, it’s pretty straightforward. It’s an amber ale” -Aaron, “I like it.” -Jenny, “Aint nothing unusual about it. It’s bitter like a bear.” -Matt. 5.8%ABV. *Year-Round*

[50/50] 29. Eye of the Hawk (Mendocino Brewing Company) “This tastes like an ale, it’s definitely got more hops than I normally enjoy. ..has notes of grain and grass.” -Aaron, “This tastes predatory..” -Matt. 8.0%ABV. *Year-Round*

[*] 30. New Holland Ichabod Ale (New Holland Brewing Company) “Matt your beer is not headless” -Aaron, “I don’t like pumpkin ales typically um–oh wow it’s got cinnamon on the back end, HOLY MOLY. ..I like the way it first hits your palate” -Matt, “That’s good” -Jason. 5.5%ABV *Fall*

[*] 31. Founders Curmudgeon Old Ale (Founders Brewing Company) “Every sip is like a punch in the face.” -Matt. 9.8%ABV. *Rotating*
-Dr. Who Game-&-Time Travel-&-Dr. Who Mad Libs-

[*] 32. Rocky’s Revenge Bourbon Brown (Tyranena Brewing Company) “I’ve had this beer before, it’s one of my current favorites and I can’t wait to DRANK IT! …It’s very caramely, A real easy drinking beer, you could drink it outside at a picnic or a function” -Matt, “This beer has a smooth, rich taste; goes down fairly easy. …You could drink it in your Tardis waiting to go to Metebelis III” -Aaron. 6.0%ABV. *Year-Round*

[N/A] 33. Tallgrass 8-Bit Pale Ale (Tallgrass Brewing Company) “It’s got quite the visual motiff.” -Matt. 5.2%ABV. *Year-Round*
-Scruples-&-Social Skills-

[*] 34. Oktoberfest (Capital Brewery) “There’s a real good color on this, I like the deep golden amber.” -Matt. 5.5%ABV. *Fall*

[*] 35. Hop Cream (Capital Brewery) “This is as good as the Winter Skål, I like the way that the Capital Brewery does hops.” -Aaron 5.3% *RETIRED BEER*

[*] 36. Dark Doppelbock (Capital Brewery) “I really like it, this is probably my favorite beer.” -Aaron, “It’s almost creamy, I like it though.” -Casem. 7.8%ABV. *RETIRED BEER*


-IRPMUS-&-Drinking Quest (The Original Drinking RPG)-

[*] 37. Fat Tire Amber Ale (New Belgium Brewing) “It’s metallic but not in an unpleasant way; it’s very bold on your palate.” -Matt, “I like it it tastes pretty good!.” -Aaron. 5.2%ABV. *Year-Round*

[X] 38. 1554 Enlightened Black Ale (New Belgium Brewing) “”It tastes like sausage casing, I’m not hugely excited about this beer. It’s a mean beer” -Aaron, “Oh that’s rough, this is really smokey. There is not a lot of pleasantness to it. It’s the kind of beer to murder a man in the forest and leave them to die.” -Matt. 5.6%ABV. *Year-Round*


-Mongolian Goat Rodeo-&-Man Bites Dog-

[*] 39. Ayinger Celebrator Doppelbock (Privatbrauerei Franz Inselkammer KG / Brauerei Aying) “This is very complex, I taste chocolate.” -Matt. 6.7%ABV. *Year-Round*

[X] 40. Dark Horse Perkulator Coffee Dopplebock (Dark Horse Brewing Company) “It smells chalky, blegh! It tastes like edamame, it paralyzes your face a bit.” -Matt, “It tastes chalky.” -Aaron. 7.0%ABV. *Rotating Availability*
-Mall of Horror: Zombie game- & -Zombie Flux-

[X] 41. Witch Hunt Spiced Harvest Ale (BridgePort Brewing Co.) “Tastes a bit like a Belgian” -Linda, “It is smooth and spicy; it has a bit of a metallic edge to it which I’m not crazy about.” -Matt. 5.8%ABV. *Fall*

[N/A] 42. Witches’ Brew Golden Ale (Brouwerij Van Steenberge N.V.) “It doesn’t even taste like a Golden Ale, it tastes heavy.” -Linda, “It is certainly heavy, it’s got quite a body to it.” -Matt. 9.3%ABV. *Fall*
-Settlers of Catan-

[*] 43. Bell’s Amber Ale (Bell’s Brewery, Inc.) “It’s very bitter, I thought it would meet me half way but it went all the way to the edge.” -Aaron, “That’s a good beer.” -David. 5.8%ABV. *Year-Round*

[50/50] 44. Ole Smoky’s Moonshine Cherries (Ole Smoky’s Moonshine) “Dur Dur Dur Dur Dur…” -Matt. 100Proof. *Year-Round*

[*] 45. Two Hearted Ale (Bell’s Brewery, Inc.) “My favorite fucking beer, good choice. It’s actually the best beer in the country.” -Andrew, “This beer does not have a bite to it and I think that’s a good thing, it’s very subtle, and it’s so smooth; you never think of a pale ale as being smooth.” -Aaron. 7.0%ABV. *Year-Round*



[50/50] 46. Samuel Adams Winter Lager (Boston Beer Company) “Tastes like a sweet punch, it’s sweet and fruity.” -Matt, “It tastes like an orange just shit out some nutmeg into my mouth.” -Jason. 5.6%ABV. *Winter*

[X] 47. Samuel Adams White Christmas (Boston Beer Company) “Holy Nutmeg!” -Matt, “I’m getting a soap quality.” -Jason. 5.8%ABV. *Winter*



-PEANUTS: Charlie Brown Christmas Game-&-Cards Against Humanity-&-Hungry Hungry Hippo-

[*] 48. Pumpkinataur Wrex (Capital Brewery) “It smells better than most beers.” -Paul, “This is good, it tastes like pumpkin pie.” -Aaron. 7.5%ABV. *Limited*

[*] 49. Winter Skål – Capital Brewery 5.4%ABV. *Winter*

[*] 50. Capital Dark (Capital Brewery) “That tastes really good, it tastes really dark and earthy” -Aaron 5.4%ABV. *Year-Round*